Another Book Biography: The Berlin Akhmimic Proverbs Codex

In my last post on the use of waste papyrus in covers of ancient codices, I made reference to the Berlin Coptic Proverbs codex (Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin, Ms. or. oct. 987, LDAB 107968). This reminded me that I had intended for some time to make a post dedicated to this book. It is a single-quire papyrus codex containing the book of Proverbs in the Akhmimic dialect of Coptic. It’s generally assigned to the fourth century, although earlier and later dates have been proposed. It was purchased in Cairo by Bernhard Moritz with the help of the Coptologist Carl Schmidt in 1905, and it was in a remarkable state of preservation at that time. Regrettably, there is, as far as I know, only one photograph showing the codex in roughly the state in which it was acquired:

Berlin Proverbs 987 bw

Image source: John Lawrence Sharpe, “The Earliest Bindings with Wooden Board Covers:
The Coptic Contribution to Binding Construction.” Pages 2.455-2.478 in Carlo Federici and Paola F. Munafò (eds.), International Conference on Conservation and Restoration of Archival and Library Materials; 2 vols. (Rome: Istituto centrale per la patologia del libro, 1999)

After it was brought to Berlin, the famed conservator Hugo Ibscher took apart the codex and mounted the individual sheets between glass plates, as was the customary practice at the time. Ibscher’s written report (published posthumously by Böhlig) was not very detailed, but it did include some interesting observations. For instance, Ibscher removed the decorated leather cover and commented in passing that some of the waste papyri used to stiffen the cover were inscribed:

“The book cover consists of 6-8 layers of papyrus, which were glued together to form a a sturdy board. The outer layers of leaves of this board contain remains of Greek letters, while the inner are apparently uninscribed (Der Buchdeckel besteht aus 6-8 Papyruslagen, die übereinandergeklebt eine starke Pappe ergaben. Die äußeren Blattlagen dieser Pappe enthalten griechische Schriftreste, während die inneren anscheinend unbeschrieben sind).”

Does anyone know what happened to these papyri? I don’t. It is possible that they are still retained with the cover, which is where they seem to have been when this photograph was taken around 1951.

Coptic Proverbs Berlin 987 small
Image source: Hans H. Bockwitz, “Zur Geschichte von Karton und Pappe im Zeitalter der Handpapiermacherei,” in Karton im Wandel der Zeit (Hillegossen, 1951), p. 12.

If the papyri from the cover contain dated documents, they could provide an aid to establishing the date of the construction of the codex. As far as I know, these papyri remain unstudied. I would be grateful if anyone who has further information about them would let us know in the comments.

In any event, this kind of disassembly of a codex was fairly typical in the early part of the twentieth century. Where the story of the Berlin Proverbs codex diverges from that of most papyrus codices is in the late 1950s, when Alexander Böhlig pressed for the rebinding of the codex. In 1958-1959, Rolf Ibscher (son of Hugo, who had died in 1943) carried out the task by covering the papyrus sheets with silk and rebinding them. The original cover was too damaged to be reused, so Werner Kießig was enlisted to create a replica of the cover.

Berlin Proverbs 987 Rebound.jpg

Berlin, Ms. or. oct. 987 in its modern binding; image source: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin

The decision to rebind has benefits and drawbacks. The newly rebound artifact probably gives a decent sense of what the original must have looked like, but the rebinding of the sheets also prevents close study of the original binding technique, so we must still rely on Hugo Ibscher’s sparse report.

At about the same time as this rebinding took place, a full photo-facsimile was produced for sale (1963). The pictures were printed on paper and bound as a single quire (including stubs in the appropriate places!), and it was also bound in a replica leather cover):

Berlin Codex Facsimile for Sale

The facsimile edition of the Berlin Proverbs Codex (right) with accompanying booklet by Alexander Böhlig (left)

Berlin Proverbs Facsimile

View of the single quire construction of the facsimile edition of the Berlin Proverbs Codex

And recently, the whole codex has been digitized. All the pages and the new binding can be viewed online at the Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin.

Berlin Proverbs 987 website

Bibliography:

Auster, G., Alexander Böhlig, Rolf Ibscher, and Werner Kießig, “Zur Umkonservierung des Papyrus-codex Ms. or. oct. 987.” Zentralblatt für Bibliothekswesen 73 (1959), 356-374.

Böhlig, Alexander. Der achmimische Proverbientext nach Ms. Berol. orient. oct. 987. Teil I: Text und Rekonstruktion der sahidischen Vorlage. Munich: Verlag Robert Lerche, 1958. (Includes a description of the manuscript by Hugo Ibscher)

 

 

This entry was posted in Berlin Coptic Proverbs Codex, Book binding, Book covers, Codices. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Another Book Biography: The Berlin Akhmimic Proverbs Codex

  1. Here’s a negative result: Archaeology of Medieval Bookbinding by J. A. Szirmai (1999/2000) has a brief discussion of Ms. or. oct. 987 but, despite extensive bibliography in the book, mentions nothing about its cartonnage dating. Maybe Myriam Krutzsch would know something.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s